The Subaru Crosstrek, known for its rugged design, off-road capability, and reliability, has become a favorite among drivers looking for a compact crossover. However, not every Crosstrek model year is created equal. Some have faced significant mechanical issues, recalls, and consumer complaints. If you’re considering buying a used Crosstrek, it’s essential to know which years might cause more headaches than joy. To help, here are the Subaru Crosstrek Years to Avoid.
Why Some Subaru Crosstrek Models Are Problematic?
Subaru is known for building reliable vehicles, but even the best manufacturers can encounter problems. For the Crosstrek, several factors contributed to the issues seen in specific years, such as:
- Design flaws in critical components (e.g., CVT transmission issues, oil consumption problems).
- New technology glitches, including infotainment and driver-assist system malfunctions.
- Production changes or new engine options, often bring teething problems.
- Cost-cutting measures in materials or outsourced parts lead to quality issues.
Breakdown of Problematic Subaru Crosstrek Years
2017 Subaru Crosstrek
Common Problems:
- Excessive oil consumption in some engines requires frequent refills.
- Issues with the CVT transmission such as delayed response and jerking.
- Premature brake wear, causing owners to replace brakes sooner than expected.
Reported Complaints:
- Owners reported frustration with oil levels dropping between services, along with performance issues related to the transmission.
- Some also experienced rough driving on highways, requiring early maintenance.
2019 Subaru Crosstrek
Common Problems:
- Eyesight Driver Assist System malfunctions, such as false braking and warnings.
- Engine stalling at low speeds, creating safety concerns.
- Frequent infotainment glitches—Bluetooth connectivity issues and frozen screens.
Recalls:
- Subaru issued recalls for problems related to engine performance and the Eyesight system, but some owners continued to experience these issues even after repairs.
2020 Subaru Crosstrek
Common Problems:
- Continuation of infotainment issues from the 2019 model.
- Weak engine performance, with drivers reporting sluggish acceleration.
- Minor suspension problems that impacted ride quality on uneven terrain.
Market Feedback:
- While many drivers praised the Crosstrek’s all-wheel-drive performance, others found the 2.0L engine underpowered.
- The issues with the infotainment system persisted, leading to poor consumer feedback. Moreover, people can read about Subaru Forester Years to Avoid.
2021 Subaru Crosstrek
Common Problems:
- Engine misfire issues in early production models, affecting acceleration.
- Recurring infotainment bugs—frozen screens, system reboots, and Bluetooth failures.
- Paint quality concerns, with reports of chipping and peeling after minimal use.
What Went Wrong in These Years?
Several factors contributed to the issues seen in these model years:
- 2017: An aging design and old components nearing the end of their lifecycle.
- 2019-2021: The introduction of new technologies (like Eyesight and updated infotainment) came with bugs.
- Engine changes in 2021: While offering more power, the new engine also introduced reliability issues early in production.
These problems reflect common issues automakers face during production transitions, technology updates, and cost management.
Should You Still Consider Buying These Models?
If you’re still considering one of these model years, here are some things to keep in mind:
- Look for a Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Vehicle: Buying a CPO model ensures the car has undergone a thorough inspection and comes with a warranty.
- Check Maintenance Records: A well-maintained Crosstrek is less likely to encounter problems, so request the vehicle’s service history.
- Inspect for Recalls: Make sure any outstanding recalls have been addressed by the previous owner.
- Hire a Mechanic for Inspection: Before finalizing a purchase, get the vehicle checked by a trusted mechanic to ensure it’s in good condition.
Alternatives to Consider
If you decide to avoid the problematic years, here are some better options:
Better Subaru Crosstrek Years:
- 2018 Subaru Crosstrek: This model fixed many of the issues seen in the 2017 model, making it a reliable choice.
- 2022 and newer models: Subaru introduced better engine options and addressed most of the infotainment bugs, making these models more dependable.
Other Compact Crossovers to Consider:
- Mazda CX-30: Known for sporty handling and reliability.
- Toyota C-HR: Offers excellent reliability and low maintenance costs.
- Honda HR-V: Another well-rounded, reliable alternative in the same segment.
While the Subaru Crosstrek remains a popular crossover, not every model year delivers the same level of reliability. The 2017, 2019, 2020, and 2021 models have faced numerous issues, from engine performance problems to persistent infotainment glitches. If you’re considering one of these years, be prepared for potential repairs and maintenance challenges or, better yet, opt for a more reliable model. These years are among the Subaru Crosstrek Years to Avoid.
Q: What is the most reliable Subaru Crosstrek year?
A: The 2018 model is often recommended due to its improved reliability over previous years.
Q: Are 2019-2021 Crosstrek models unsafe?
A: No, they are not unsafe, but they come with issues related to performance and electrical systems that could be frustrating to deal with.
Q: Is the Crosstrek worth buying despite these issues?
A: Yes, but only if the vehicle has been well-maintained or comes with a warranty. Buyers should consider a thorough inspection before making a decision.
